Spicier food in hot countries has been explained in terms of natural selection on human cultures, with spices with antimicrobial effects considered to be an adaptation to increased risk of foodborne infection. However, correlations between culture and environment are difficult to interpret, because many cultural traits are inherited together from shared ancestors, neighbouring cultures are exposed to similar conditions, and many cultural and environmental variables show strong covariation. Here, using a global dataset of 33,750 recipes from 70 cuisines containing 93 different spices, we demonstrate that variation in spice use is not explained by temperature and that spice use cannot be accounted for by diversity of cultures, plants, crops or naturally occurring spices. Patterns of spice use are not consistent with an infection-mitigation mechanism, but are part of a broader association between spice, health, and poverty. This study highlights the challenges inherent in interpreting patterns of human cultural variation in terms of evolutionary pressures.
Author(s): Lindell Bromham , Alexander Skeels , Hilde Schneemann , Russell Dinnage1, Xia Hua
Year: 2021
Language: English
Commentary: move to scimag
Pages: 16
Tags: Spices, Climate, Infection, Poverty
There is little evidence that spicy food in hot countries is an adaptation to reducing infection risk
Results
Discussion
Methods
Cuisines
Autocorrelation between cuisines
Infection risk
Climate and biodiversity
Socioeconomic and human population variables
Statistical analysis
Modelling autocorrelation
Power analysis
Model comparisons
Reporting Summary
Acknowledgements
Fig. 1 Spice and temperature.
Fig. 2 Horrendogram of proposed links between spice use and infection risk.
Fig. 3 Spice and GDP.
Fig. 4 Spice and traffic accidents.
Fig. 5 Geographic sampling bias.
Table 1 Recipe datasets included in this study, including the original data used in a previous study of adaptive cuisine2 and data from four published recipe datasets3–5.
Table 2 Summary of main results corresponding to links in Fig.
Table 3 List of spices counted in this study.
