Popular Political Participation and the Democratic Imagination in Spain: From Crowd to People, 1766-1868

This document was uploaded by one of our users. The uploader already confirmed that they had the permission to publish it. If you are author/publisher or own the copyright of this documents, please report to us by using this DMCA report form.

Simply click on the Download Book button.

Yes, Book downloads on Ebookily are 100% Free.

Sometimes the book is free on Amazon As well, so go ahead and hit "Search on Amazon"

This book addresses the changing relationships among political participation, political representation, and popular mobilization in Spain from the 1766 protest in Madrid against the early Bourbon reforms until the citizen revolution of 1868 that first introduced universal suffrage and led to the ousting of the monarchy.

Popular Participation and the Democratic Imagination in Spain shows that a notion of the “crowd” internally dividing the concept of “people” existed before the advent of Liberalism, allowing for the enduring subordination of popular participation to representation in politics.

In its wider European and colonial American context, the study analyzes semantic changes in a range of cultural spheres, from parliamentary debate to historical narrative and aesthetics. It shows how Liberalism had trouble reproducing the legitimacy of limited suffrage and traces the evolution of an imagination on democracy that would allow for the reconfiguration of an all-encompassing image of the people eventually overcoming representative government.

“Focused on the nation and identities, Spanish historiography had a pending debt with that other historical subject of modernity, the people. With this book, Pablo Sánchez León starts cancelling the debt with an innovative methodology combining conceptual history with social and political history. Brilliantly, this books also proposes a novel chronology for modern history and renewed categories of analysis. In many senses, this is an extraordinarily renovating senior work.”

―José María Portillo Valdés, University of the Basque Country, Spain 

“This book by Pablo Sánchez León is an original and detailed study of one of the essential components of modernity, the relation between the concepts of plebe and pueblo. The author shows that plebe and people were shaped in a process of mutual differentiation and how the enduring tension between them deeply marked out the evolution of Spanish politics from the end of the Old Regime and throughout the 19th century. As the author brilliantly argues, such tension is tightly imbricated with the enduring dilemma between representation and participation underlying modern political systems. Through a historical analysis of the influence of people and plebe over Spanish, the book makes clear the degree to which the power of language contributes to shape political actors and institutional frames.”

―Miguel Ángel Cabrera ― Professor, University of La Laguna, Tenerife, Spain 

“Most accounts of Spain’s transition to modern democracy begin with the popular uprising against the French invasion in 1808, the creation of a national parliament and the promulgation of an advanced Liberal constitution in 1812. Pablo Sánchez León begins the story half a century earlier in the mass street protests in Madrid and other cities in 1766 sparked by Charles III’s sweeping reform programme. Sánchez León focuses unrepentantly on plebeian groups and crowd action – how they are described and conceived by contemporaries – as a key to understanding Spain’s precocious and troubled passage from absolutism to the promulgation of universal male suffrage in September 1868. This audacious and highly original interpretation will surely strike a chord with students of modern Spain.”

―Guy Thomson, University of Warwick, UK 

“This is a book for exploring (from current needs) the history of political participation in Spanish society in order to rethink the very notion of modern citizenship.”

―María Sierra, University of Seville, Spain 

“Motivated by the current crisis in political representation in parliamentary democracies, this work by Pablo Sánchez León departs from the process of construction of modern citizenship. Representation, participation and mobilization are put into play as an interactive triad whose dynamics and changing conceptualization have the key to the social, political and cultural changes between the Old Regime and the early establishment of democracy in 1868. The “They do not represent us!” and other current claims for deliberative democracy provide the guiding thread for a demanding research on the tension between representation and participation shaping the period 1766-1868. The work reflects on the relevance of popular participation and, in presenting the modern history of Spain as singular and relevant on its own, provides an account of the building of modern citizenship.

―Pablo Fernández Albaladejo, Autonomous University of Madrid, Spain

This exciting book is both topical and historiographically valuable. It offers a fresh perspective on current debates about the limits of representation and the pros and cons of participation; it makes Spanish political culture in the age of revolutions accessible to anglophone readers, and it engagingly illustrates one way of doing the ‘history of concepts’. Recommended on all three counts.

Joanna Innes, Oxford University

Author(s): Pablo Sánchez León
Publisher: Palgrave Macmillan
Year: 2020

Language: English
Pages: 363
City: Cham

Preface
Acknowledgements
Contents
Chapter 1: Introduction: Historizing the Language of Modern Citizenship
Representation and Participation at the Crossroads
The Differentiation Between Representation and Participation as a Modern Phenomenon
Democratic Imagination in the Passage to Modernity
The Inclusion of the Crowd as a Contingent Process
Spain, 1766–1868: Democracy in the Struggle for the Meaning of Citizenship
Works Cited
Chapter 2: Order: From Plebeian Disorder to Popular Citizenship—Constitutional Imagination Between Contexts, 1766–1814
Regime Changes and the Resignification of the Legacies of the Past
Disorder, Restoration, and Change: The Old Regime Re-signified, 1766–1774
Mobilization and Participation Without Representation: The Coining of the Plebe, 1766–1808
Constitutional Crisis, Popular Power, and Democracy-in-Corporation: 1808–1814
Epilogue and Conclusion
Works Cited
Chapter 3: Subject: Education, Taxed Wealth, Capacity, Roots—Citizenship Criteria from the Enlightenment to Liberalism, 1780s–1840s
Political Crises and Communal-Based Criteria for Citizenship
Interest Without Ownership: Citizenship Based on Education up to Early Liberalism
Rent Without Culture: Political Exclusion Based on Property in Isabelline Liberalism
Rootedness with Capacity: The Inclusive Citizenship of Evolving Doceañismo
Conclusion
Works Cited
Chapter 4: Space: The Spectre of Plebeian Tyranny—Popular Participation, Radical Leadership, and the Revolutions of 1848
Historicizing the Semantic Field of Populism
Plebeian Tyranny, a Legacy of the Old Regime
The Struggle over the Meaning of Democracy in Post-1812 Spanish Liberalism
Spain and 1848 as a Watershed in the History of the Semantic Field of Democracy
The Transnational 1848 and the Protagonism of the Crowd as a Subaltern Group
Conclusion
Works Cited
Chapter 5: Time: The Fatalist Loop—Historical Culture and Popular Empowerment in the Mid-Nineteenth Century
Citizenship, Historical Culture, and Empowerment: Now and Then
Fatalism in the Intellectual and Ideological Debates During the Isabelline Period
Conservative Hegemony and Antipopular Prejudice
The Discursive Loop of Juan Donoso Cortés in Context
The Semantic Turn of Fatalism in Historical Narrative
Epilogue and Conclusions
Works Cited
Chapter 6: Identity: Enraged Citizens or Subaltern Crowd? Popular Mobilization, Representation, and Participation in the Spanish Revolution of 1854
The Limits of Representation in Modern Citizenship
The Value of Unity and the Meaning of Democracy Among the Early Democrats
Seville, 1854: Radical Identities Without Party Representation
Madrid, 1854: Plebeian Identities Without Discursive Representation
The Aftermath of the Revolution: Unity Beyond Monarchy
Conclusions
Works Cited
Chapter 7: Recognition: Vulgar as a Political Concept—Discourse and Subjects of Corruption in the Public Sphere of Limited Suffrage
Democracy and the Figures of Corruption in the Public Sphere
Aristocracy, People, and Plebe Until the Rise of Democratic Discourse
Aesthetics and Corruption After the Failed Constituent Process of 1854–1856
Semantic Inversion in the Discourse on the Aristocracy
Conclusion: The People/Oligarchy Dichotomy and the Limits of the Vocabulary of the Mixed Constitution
Works Cited
Chapter 8: Epilogue: Decline and Fall of the Liberal Monarchy, 1865–1868
Works Cited
Chapter 9: Conclusions: Studying Modern Citizenship as Historical Condition
Beyond Conventional Narratives: Chronology, Continuity, and Change
The Relevance of Language in a Genuine Interdisciplinary Approach
Understanding Contexts in Their Fullness and the Limits of Historiographic Subdisciplines
In Favour of a History Distinguishing the Voice of the Subaltern
Towards a Complete Narrative on the Specificity of Spanish Modernity
Works Cited
Index