A masterful new account of old regime France by one of the world's most prominent political philosophers
France before 1789 traces the historical origins of France's National Constituent Assembly of 1789, providing a vivid portrait of the ancien régime and its complex social system in the decades before the French Revolution. Jon Elster writes in the spirit of Alexis de Tocqueville, who described this tumultuous era with an eye toward individual and group psychology and the functioning of institutions. Whereas Tocqueville saw the old regime as a breeding ground for revolution, Elster, more specifically, identifies the rural and urban conflicts that fueled the constitution-making process from 1789 to 1791. He presents a new approach to history writing, one that supplements the historian's craft with the tools and insights of modern social science. Elster draws on important French and Anglo-American scholarship as well as a treasure trove of historical evidence from the period, such as the Memoirs of Saint-Simon, the letters of Madame de Sévigné, the journals of the lawyer Barbier and the bookseller Hardy, the Remonstrances of Malesherbes, and La Bruyère's maxims.
Masterfully written and unparalleled in scope, France before 1789 is the first volume of a trilogy that promises to transform our understanding of constitution making in the eighteenth century. Volume 2 will look at revolutionary America in the years leading up to the Constitutional Convention of 1787 while the third volume will examine all facets of the French and American assemblies, from how they elected their delegates and organized their proceedings to how they addressed issues of separation of powers and representation.
Author(s): Jon Elster
Publisher: Princeton University Press
Year: 2020
Language: English
Pages: xiv+264
Cover
Contents
Preface
1 Introduction
The Nature of the Ancien Régime
Mechanisms: The Importance of Choice
Mechanisms: Interaction
2 The Psychology of the Main Social Groups: Motivations
Interest
Reason
Passion
The Nobility of the Robe
The Peasantry
Seigneurial Justice
The Urban Populations
The Clergy
3 The Psychology of the Main Social Groups: Information and Beliefs
Top-Down Beliefs
Bottom-Up Beliefs
Horizontal Belief Formation
4 The Royal Government and the Courts
Unwritten Constraints
The Tools of Government
Discretionary Tools
Revenues and Spending
Necker Cause of the Revolution?
The Legal System
5 Deliberating Bodies
The Estates-General (1302–1614)
The Main Provincial Estates
The Provincial Estates and the Parlements
6 Conclusion
The Limits of Our Knowledge
Exemptions and Exceptions
Scarcity, Urgency, and Uncertainty
Injustice and Norm Violations
Conspiracy Theories and Agency-Bias
Passive Resistance
Second Best?
Wars, Taxes, and Loans
Tocqueville
Appendix: Bibliographical Overview
References
Index