Substate nationalism is often studied as a question of political identity and cultural recognition. The same applies to the study of multinational federalism – it is mainly conceived as a tool for the accommodation of minority cultures and identities. Few works in political philosophy and political science pay attention to the fiscal and redistributive dimensions of substate nationalism and multinational federalism. Yet nationalist movements in Western countries make crucial claims about fiscal autonomy and the fair distribution of resources between national groups within the same state. In recent years, Scottish nationalists have demanded greater tax autonomy, Catalan and Flemish nationalists have viewed themselves as unfairly disadvantaged by centralized fiscal arrangements, and equalization payments and social transfers in Canada have exacerbated tensions within the federation. In Fiscal Federalism in Multinational States contributors from political philosophy and political science disciplines explore the fiscal side of substate nationalism in Canada, Belgium, the United Kingdom, Spain, and Australia. Chapters examine the connection between secessionist claims and interregional redistributive arrangements, power relations in federations where taxing and spending responsibilities are shared between orders of government, the relationship between substate nationalism and fiscal autonomy, and the role of federal governments in redistributing resources among substate national groups. Fiscal Federalism in Multinational States brings together scholars of nationalism and federalism in a groundbreaking analysis of the connections between nationalist claims and fiscal debates within plurinational states.
Author(s): François Boucher, Alain Noël
Series: Democracy, Diversity, and Citizen Engagement Series
Publisher: McGill-Queen's University Press
Year: 2021
Language: English
Pages: 300
City: Montreal
Cover
Copyright
Contents
Figures and Tables
Acknowledgments
Introduction Sub-State Nationalism and Fiscal Relations in Plurinational States
Part One Secession: Fiscal and Redistributive Claims
1 Nationalism, Fiscal Questions, and Self-Determination
2 Could Claims of Distribution Justify Self-Determination? A Moral Cosmopolitan Account
Part Two Power, Intergovernmental Relations, and Fiscal Federalism
3 (Dis)Empowerment and Self-Rule: Fiscal Federalism and Minority Nations in Canada
4 Is Non-Centralization an Adequate Principle for Fiscal Federalism in a Multinational Context? Reflections from the Canadian Case
Part Three Fiscal Autonomy in Multinational States
5 Scotland’s Quiet Revolution: Economic Nationalism, Fiscal Autonomy, and Business Financing
6 Multinational Federalism and Fiscal Autonomy
Part Four Equality and the Federal Government
7 Fiscal Federalism in Multinational States: An Idea of Justice
8 Egalitarian Federalism
Conclusion Fiscal Federalism for a Multinational Federation: Canada’s Experience
Contributors
Index
